top of page
  • Writer's pictureFaron

What Happen to Evergrande (恒大)

Your Top Evergrande Questions, Answered


Hong Kong-based columnist Shuli Ren spent years covering Evergrande, China’s largest real estate developer, before its plunge. She sat down with Anjani Trivedi to answer a series of questions that have come to Bloomberg Opinion from readers, investors and several others who have been closely watching the crisis unfold.



For years, Evergrande has had these moments where suddenly everyone was wondering if the company would be able to pay its dues. And this time, it really did come to its knees. So what happened, and why did this happen now?


Evergrande has been called a cat with nine lives. They’ve had many liquidity crises over the years. Short sellers have been shorting them for a good decade in Hong Kong, but every time it has survived. The problem with the cat analogy is that this cat got too fat. And this time, the combination of China’s common prosperity drive and then the sudden pull out of supply-chain financing options was too much for Evergrande. That cat had to go on a diet too fast, and it just couldn't make it. So basically, there were a lot of bills due, and Evergrande didn't have the means to pay them.


By the numbers, everything always seems larger-than-life in China. Can you put it into context?

Most of Evergrande’s projects are not in the first-tier cities of Shanghai, Beijing, Shenzhen and Guangzhou. It's spread out across the smaller cities. To give you some context, in China, third-tier cities have a population of half a million to 3 million. That’s a lot! When Evergrande did its restructuring, it sold 1.6 million apartments, pre-sold. These apartments have not even been built. So right now, the first problem that the government has to solve is to somehow find the money to build these 1.6 million apartments and give them to the consumers who have already paid the price. And that's the scale of China — 1.6 million feels like a lot for the rest of the world. We’re talking about five to six million people not having housing.


Evergrande has over $300 billion in debt due. What’s the financial state of the company?


Interestingly enough, Evergrande actually got really big during President Xi Jinping’s reign. Between 2016 and 2020, its total liabilities almost doubled to $300 billion. And it's pretty interesting because starting in late 2017, President Xi has been trying to reduce property-sector leverage. So you do wonder why Evergrande got bigger, whereas everyone else was asked to be smaller.


Evergrande is the world's most indebted real estate company in the world. Who do they owe this money to?


They owe money to pretty much everyone. Evergrande got money from suppliers, big banks, trust companies and a lot of money was owed to foreign investors. Evergrande is Asia's largest high-yield dollar bond issuer. It has about $20 billion of bonds outstanding, and the foreigners have a big chunk of that.


There's been a lot of anxiety in global markets as to whether this is systemic enough to cause contagion and have wider ramifications. Do you think there will be some form of contagion —whether it’s a lack of confidence or a shift in the way people look at China?


I would prefer to be on the optimistic side. Evergrande is big, but it's about as big as Anbang Insurance Group or HNA Group Co. And Evergrande is not a financial company. It's a real estate developer. In the worst case, it has the lending banks; it has the unfinished projects. So, in a sense, the recovery rate for Chinese consumers and suppliers is better. On the contagion front, global markets are a little bit freaked out in part because of Evergrande’s dollar bond issues outside China. And also, it had relationships with 128 banks. It didn't say which banks, but you do want to know. Well, how about HSBC Holdings Plc? How about JPMorgan Chase & Co? Citigroup Inc.? They are all big players in the Hong Kong market.


What’s the worst-case scenario in terms of an end game?


I think the worst-case scenario would be street protests in China. Evergrande owes everyone a lot of money. We're talking about consumers who bought apartments from them. Evergrande also sold wealth management products to its consumers, to its employees, and small businesses suppliers. There’s the potential for a lot of protests, and the government really doesn't want to deal with that.


People are selling stocks and bonds before they're really asking the question of what exactly went wrong this time. That is definitely a problem. So let’s get to the bottom of it: What was the issue with Evergrande?


We have talked about indebtedness a lot. But one question that I think people need to start digging into is: How about working capital management? In the past year, we have seen some disruption of supply chain financing — Greensill was an example. When Greensill went bust, some of Masayoshi Son’s unicorn tech startups also went bust. Evergrande’s problem is a working capital problem. It was stretched too thin, and it had too little working capital cash. So, I think that people need to start looking at the supply chain side of things.

All of this has really happened over the past few years. How did Evergrande get this big under the reign of President Xi Jinping?


Billionaire founder Xu Jiayin was quite connected and ahead of his time. In a well-cited 2018 speech, Jiayin spoke about common prosperity, which was far in advance of President Xi’s common prosperity push. So, he felt that he was doing the politically correct thing by catering to the smaller tier-three cities. When you have China's largest or second-largest real estate developer coming to a small city, the local government puts the red carpet out.


What should foreign investors be thinking right now? Where do things stand?


Everybody is expecting Evergrande to default. So why hasn’t China formed a creditors’ committee? And what about the recovery rate? In addition to getting those questions answered, people need to start digging into the supply chain financing issues.


Original Article

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-09-24/what-happened-to-evergrande-and-china-s-real-estate-market

3 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

跟着政府买,是不是包赚?/韭哥

跟着政府买股票就包赚吗? 我当年(2012)一进货就买马银行,大众银行的时候,是这样想的。 大蓝筹有赚头 但是10多年后的今天,看回去,也就只有马银行,联昌国际,大众银行等大蓝筹有赚到点,剩下的很多,我买过的,没买过的,都亏惨。股民当韭菜,政府当韭王。 亏的比较有代表性的,我第一个想起的是马航,当年财政部7、8块买,很多阿北也跟着买,结果都变成了韭菜。这是典型经营不善的漏水屋,然后2014再来MH

马股曾发生过的腥风血雨……

1)电脑纸 电脑纸(CFM,8044,主板工业产品服务组)股价去年11月中旬开始攀涨,从1令吉14仙一度飙升至2令吉92仙,涨幅超过150%,但今年2月24日开始突然狂泻不止,跌回1令吉50仙水平线下,劲挫约48%。 较后,该股更开启了长达10个交易日的跌风,股价两周遭“砍半”,同时还跌停板,不寻常波动遭交易所发出UMA,惟电脑纸回应不知情。 随着股价跌风四起,去年8月受委独立兼非执行副主席拿督斯

蔡兆源 | 钱藏在税务天堂就没事吗?

国内政治风云再起,《巴拿马泄密事件》再次成为焦点。全球不少政商名流的名字都出现在巴拿马—间著名的信托秘书服务公司的客户名单中,震撼全球。之前,此泄密事件甚至导致某国的总理下台。某些富豪在“税务天堂”成立岸外信托(Trust)或基金会(Foundation)来规划其遗产与企业传承,以加强其保密度。但也有些纳税人,为了避税(Tax Avoidance)或是逃税(Tax Evasion),将钱藏在“税务

Comments


bottom of page